The debate about whether to place a question on the ballot for the upcoming election is underway.
It seems Councillors Gartner & Granger want to be able to point to something they did (and can explain without notes) when asked about their contribution this past term. Mayor Phyllis Morris and Councillor MacEachern have acquiesced to their request for the very own motion (although surely written by others) — although Councillor MacEachern has already is quoted as stating “representation-at-large is best”. It make one wonder why they bother since MacEachern has already stated her preference. And we have seen the voting record for a motion by MacEachern.
The real issue behind the question is whether a ward system will increase the performance and accountability of Council. If the answer is “Yes”, then a case can be made. However, if there is no difference — then why change.
In business, you are faced with questions where there are no clear answers. The best way to discover the answers is to keep asking the question “WHY?”, until eventually the answers start to become clearer.
From our view, we were pleased to hear that Council will share their thinking and be presenting information to inform the public — and hiding behind the skirts of “the public said so” — before simply holding an Open House and wasting everyone’s time and our tax dollars. Citizens need to be provided with information so they can make “informed” comments, rather than just react emotionally.
In the interim, here are a few initial thoughts to get the discussion started.
- Currently each citizen can call 8 Councillors and 1 Mayor if they have an issue. A ward system reduces that number.
- Currently you can call any Councillor, a Ward system may force me to call someone you don’t like and/or didn’t vote for.
- Currently we get to pick up to 8 — the best of a long list. The list will shorten and potentially new candidates won’t have the same ability to unseat incumbents.
- Wards work for the benefit of politicians. Less area to campaign, less issues to advocate on behalf of.
- Ward Councillors take a ward focused view. They tend to vote for what works for their ward since they need to solicit votes from a smaller voter pool who are focused on their own interests. They tend not to look at the bigger picture. Councillors at large have no such affiliation so they can vote for the greater good more often.
- Reducing the Councillors who represent my interests (my ward) does not increase their accountability. It just means less people who will take your call.
Frankly, we see no compelling reason for a change. Do you?
Agree or disagree?


